Open Navigation

Breakdown in Trust and Confidence

Helping you navigate an employment relationship which has become untenable

Issues can arise in an employee/employer relationship which result in an employer or an employee feeling they no longer have faith or trust in the other. Situations such as these can be emotionally charged and difficult to identify in the first place, but if dealt with appropriately may be a fair reason for dismissal.

Breakdown in Trust and Confidence

Where an employee is found to have committed an act or acts of misconduct it may mean that an employer no longer has trust in the employee and it would not be feasible for the employee to return to work.

Under section 98 Employment Rights Act 1998 (“ERA”) a potentially fair reason for dismissal is “some other substantial reason of a kind such as to justify the dismissal of an employee holding the position which the employee held”. This is a catch-all category to deal with reasons which are not identified elsewhere in the ERA. One example of a potentially fair reason for dismissal under this category is a breakdown of trust and confidence.

Where an employer is seeking to rely on this reason to dismiss an employee it should always undertake a fair and thorough investigation into the allegations, and the employee should be notified that this is an allegation against them in a letter inviting them to a disciplinary hearing. Employment Tribunals have been critical of employers who attempt to use the notion of a breakdown of trust and confidence as a blanket reason for dismissal. It will be necessary for an employer to have evidence of specific circumstances which show why they no longer have faith in the employee. It will not be sufficient to simply refer to broad or vague reasons. Employers should also generally avoid relying on a breakdown in trust and confidence as the only reason for a dismissal. In a dismissal situation a breakdown in trust and confidence is often cited as a reason for dismissal linked to findings of misconduct for example that in light of the misconduct an employer has lost confidence in the employee to such an extent that is not feasible that the individual can return to work.

News

Skilled Worker Route

The new Skilled Worker Route will go live on 1 December 2020. This route replaces the Tier 2 Sponsorship scheme and is at the core of the new approach to UK immigration policy as the country prepares to leave the EU single market on 31 December 2020. The Home Office has now published an extensive…

Read More
US Immigration

Immigration 2021

We are delighted to announce that the Minister of State for Future Borders and Immigration has agreed to be the keynote speaker and panellist at the last of our virtual Immigration 2021 events on 30 November. As we approach the end of 2020, global mobility policy and practice is at an unprecedented juncture. Three exceptional…

Read More

Furlough Extension Guidance Published – But Many Questions Remain

Employers will be all too aware that until recently it looked as though the furlough, or Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme (CJRS), would end on 31 October 2020 and be replaced by the less generous Job Support Scheme. The CJRS was initially only extended to 31 January 2021. However, on 5 November 2020, Rishi Sunak announced…

Read More